Most frauds and costly errors in small NGOs are not clever. They happen because one person can start, approve and record a payment, and nobody checks afterwards. A short list of controls, actually followed, closes most of that gap.
This checklist is for small and mid-sized NGOs, nonprofits and charities anywhere, with a finance team of one to five people. Larger organisations will need more, but rarely less.
General guidance for governance and education. Your auditor and your donors' rules may set more specific requirements.
The one principle behind every control
No single person should be able to complete a transaction from start to finish without someone else seeing it. That is segregation of duties. Where a small team cannot split the work, the fix is a review by someone independent, after the event, every time.
The 20-point checklist
| # | Control | Yes / Partly / No |
|---|---|---|
| Cash and bank | ||
| 1 | Bank accounts are opened and closed only with a Board resolution | |
| 2 | Every payment needs two people: one to prepare, one to approve (in online banking too) | |
| 3 | Bank reconciliations are done monthly and reviewed and signed by someone who cannot make payments | |
| 4 | Cash in hand has a limit, is counted by surprise, and petty cash is topped up only against receipts | |
| Payments and suppliers | ||
| 5 | A written delegation of authority says who may approve what, up to what amount | |
| 6 | New suppliers and changes to supplier bank details are checked by phone with a known contact before use | |
| 7 | Purchases above a set amount need quotes, and the reason for the choice is recorded | |
| 8 | No payment is made without an invoice and proof that goods or services were received | |
| Payroll and people | ||
| 9 | Joiners, leavers and pay changes are approved in writing by someone outside the payroll team | |
| 10 | The payroll total is checked against the previous month, and differences are explained | |
| 11 | Advances to staff are recorded, approved and settled within a set time | |
| Income and grants | ||
| 12 | Donations and receipts are recorded by someone other than the person who banks them | |
| 13 | Each restricted grant has its own code, and spending is tracked against its budget monthly | |
| 14 | Donor reports are reconciled to the accounting records before they are sent | |
| Assets and records | ||
| 15 | A fixed asset register exists and is checked physically once a year | |
| 16 | Accounting system access is by named user, with no shared passwords | |
| 17 | Data is backed up, and at least one copy is held outside the office | |
| Oversight | ||
| 18 | The Board (or its finance committee) sees management accounts at least quarterly | |
| 19 | The auditor's management letter is discussed by the Board, and each point has an owner and date | |
| 20 | Staff know how to raise a concern about money, and it reaches someone outside finance | |
Separating duties in a team of two or three
| Task | Accountant | CEO or director | Treasurer or Board member |
|---|---|---|---|
| Prepare payments | Yes | ||
| Approve payments in the bank | Yes | Second approver above a limit | |
| Add or change a supplier's bank details | Enters | Approves after a call-back | |
| Monthly bank reconciliation | Prepares | Reviews and signs | |
| Payroll changes | Processes | Approves | Reviews CEO's own pay |
The treasurer's monthly review takes less than an hour. It is the cheapest insurance a small organisation can buy.
Warning signs the controls are not working
- Bank reconciliations are months behind, or "nearly balance".
- One person never takes leave and nobody else can do their work.
- The same few suppliers win every quote, or quotes look alike.
- Supplier bank details changed by email request.
- Donor reports are prepared from spreadsheets that do not match the accounts.
Questions people ask
What are internal controls in a nonprofit?
Internal controls are the everyday checks that make sure money and assets are used as intended and records are right: who can approve a payment, who checks the bank reconciliation, who can add a supplier, and so on. They protect the organisation and the staff who handle money.
How can a small nonprofit separate duties with only one or two finance staff?
Use the Board and the CEO as the second pair of eyes. For example, the accountant prepares payments, the CEO approves them in the bank, and a Board member (often the treasurer) reviews the bank statement and reconciliation each month. Where duties cannot be split, add a review after the event.
What is the most important control for a small NGO?
A monthly bank reconciliation that is reviewed and signed by someone who cannot make payments. It catches most errors and many frauds within weeks rather than years.
How often should internal controls be reviewed?
Once a year as a whole, usually with the auditor's management letter, and whenever there is a change in finance staff, systems or bank mandates.