A Board that never looks at itself usually finds out about its gaps from an auditor, a donor or a crisis. A short self-assessment once a year is the cheapest way to find them first.
This page is for chairs, trustees and directors of NGOs, nonprofits, charities and foundations anywhere: a nonprofit board in the US, charity trustees in the UK, or an NGO board in Kenya, Nigeria, Uganda, South Africa or India. The questions are the same; only the words change.
General guidance for governance and education. Adapt it to your organisation's size, law and constitution.
How to score
Each member answers every question on a simple four-point scale, on their own and before the meeting:
| Score | Meaning |
|---|---|
| 3 | Yes, and we can show it (a paper, a minute, a policy that is followed) |
| 2 | Mostly, but not written down or not done every time |
| 1 | Sometimes, or only when someone pushes |
| 0 | No, or I don't know |
"I don't know" counts as 0. If a Board member does not know whether something happens, the Board is not overseeing it.
The 25 questions
A. Purpose and strategy
- Can every member state the mission and the three priorities for this year in the same words?
- Did the Board approve the strategy, and does it review progress against it at least twice a year?
- Do Board agendas spend more time on the future than on reports of the past?
- Has the Board said what it will not do, even if a donor would pay for it?
- Does the Board know which programmes depend on a single donor?
B. Oversight of money and risk
- Does the Board see a finance report it understands, with cash, reserves and forecast, at every meeting?
- Is there a written reserves policy, and do we know how many months we can run if income stops?
- Does the Board review a risk register and change decisions because of it?
- Does the Board meet the auditor, and read the management letter, not only the signed accounts?
- Do we know our legal and regulatory deadlines, and who confirms they were met?
C. People and leadership
- Does the Board appraise the CEO each year against agreed goals?
- Is there a written plan if the CEO or finance head leaves suddenly?
- Does the Board approve the CEO's pay and the overall pay policy?
- Do staff have a safe way to raise concerns that reaches the Board?
- Is safeguarding of the people we serve on the Board agenda at least once a year?
D. How the Board works
- Do we have the skills we need (finance, law, programme, technology, fundraising), and do we know which are missing?
- Do members declare conflicts of interest every year and at every meeting where they arise?
- Are papers sent at least a week ahead, and do members read them?
- Are there term limits, and is there a plan for new members and the next chair?
- Do new members get an induction before their first meeting?
E. Accountability and trust
- Do donors and regulators get accurate, timely reports without last-minute rush?
- Do we publish our annual report and accounts where the public can find them?
- Does the Board hear directly from the people we serve, at least once a year?
- Has the Board's own performance been discussed openly in the last 12 months?
- Would the Board be comfortable if this year's minutes were published in a newspaper?
Reading the results
| Total (out of 75) | What it usually means |
|---|---|
| 60 to 75 | A working Board. Pick the two lowest questions and fix them this year. |
| 40 to 59 | The basics exist, but much depends on a few people. Write down what is done by habit. |
| Below 40 | Oversight is thin. Start with finance, risk and the CEO appraisal (questions 6 to 11). |
The total matters less than the spread. If one member scores a question 3 and another 0, the Board does not share the same picture. That conversation is the real value of the exercise.
Running it in one meeting
- Two weeks before: send the 25 questions. Ask for answers to a neutral person, not the chair.
- One week before: that person shares the average and the range for each question, with no names.
- At the meeting (60 minutes): discuss only the five questions with the lowest average or the widest range.
- After: agree three actions, each with an owner and a date, and minute them. Check them at the next meeting.
Common mistakes
- Turning it into a vote of confidence. The review is about how the Board works, not about any person.
- Scoring by agreement in the room. People soften their scores in front of the chair. Collect them privately.
- No actions. A review that produces no change next year teaches the Board that it doesn't matter.
- Looking only at the Board. A Board can work well while the organisation around it has weak controls. That is why a wider governance check is worth doing as well.
Questions people ask
How often should a nonprofit Board assess itself?
Once a year is the norm, usually a few months before the annual general meeting or the Board calendar is set. A short check on one or two areas can be added after a major event, such as a new chair or a crisis.
Who should run a Board self-assessment?
The chair or the governance committee owns it, but someone neutral should collect the answers so members can be honest. Every second or third year, an outside facilitator adds a fresh view.
Should the CEO take part in the Board self-assessment?
Yes, as one voice. The CEO sees the Board from the other side of the table and often notices gaps the Board does not. Keep the CEO's answers separate so the Board can compare the two views.
What is the difference between a Board self-assessment and a governance assessment?
A Board self-assessment looks at how the Board itself works. A governance assessment looks wider: risk, finance, compliance, people and systems across the whole organisation. A Board can score itself well while the organisation around it is weak.